Manage Blogs

Login
Login NOT required for comments

Latest Comments

Paul Walwyn commented on
Final English Championships
Pete Eccleston commented on
Week from 18th/19th August 2018
Dominic Watts commented on
Weekend 10th/11th March 2018
Andy harmer commented on
Ladybower Inn, 31st January 2018
Willy Kitchen commented on
Week from 21st/22nd October 2017

Coming Up

Club run
Sportsman
Wed 24th Oct
6:30pm
Warts run
Rowlee Bridge
Wed 24th Oct
6:45pm
DPFR race
Other runs
coaching
Tomorrow
6:30pm
Grin And Bear It
Sun 28th Oct
10:30am

Tweets

Totley AC
@TotleyAC
4h • 22/10/2018 • 9:36

Totley AC
@TotleyAC
4h • 22/10/2018 • 9:30

Dark Peak Fell Runners
@dpfellrunners
5h • 22/10/2018 • 8:07

Dark Peak Fell Runners
@dpfellrunners
5h • 22/10/2018 • 8:06

Dark Peak Fell Runners
@dpfellrunners
5h • 22/10/2018 • 8:03

Dark Peak Fell Runners
@dpfellrunners
5h • 22/10/2018 • 8:02

Dark Peak Fell Runners
@dpfellrunners
5h • 22/10/2018 • 8:01

Dark Peak Fell Runners
@dpfellrunners
17h • 21/10/2018 • 20:01

Mark
@1973MLB
18h • 21/10/2018 • 18:44

Malcolm Patterson
@malcpat
22h • 21/10/2018 • 15:24

Ambleside AC
@amblesideac
22h • 21/10/2018 • 15:18

Joe Baxter
@JWHBaxter
1d • 21/10/2018 • 8:10

Dark Peak Fell Runners
@dpfellrunners
1d • 21/10/2018 • 8:07

Dark Peak Fell Runners
@dpfellrunners
1d • 21/10/2018 • 8:06

Graham Brown
@broon_69
1d • 21/10/2018 • 0:44

Gareth Briggs
@gazzbb
1d • 20/10/2018 • 19:54

Dark Peak Fell Runners
@dpfellrunners
1d • 20/10/2018 • 16:11

Rydal Round
@rydal_round
1d • 20/10/2018 • 15:54

Rydal Round
@rydal_round
1d • 20/10/2018 • 15:03

From the Photos page

random_picture
posted by WillyK on 21st Nov 2014

With apologies to Carshare for invading his blog, it only seems fair that the whole club (and not just the Facebook cognoscenti) should get to comment on this one.  

We are deeply indebted to both Adi Davis and Jim Fulton for providing the tracks that allow us to pose the questions:

2014-11-21--image.jpg1. which track is Ashley's?

2. is this finally the proof we needed that great fell running minds (Jim and Ashley's) think entirely alike?

3. if 2. is conceded, then how can genetics account for the occasionally inspired variations upon variations upon a route which these two magnificent tracks reveal?

No cheating now; only answers backed up with a plausible explanation can be accepted - so don't just refer to the tracks on the website for your answer. A pint for the best set of answers, in the Carshare comments section below (comments on Facebook also welcome, though these will not qualify for beer).

Permalink | Closed to new comments (6) | Last updated on Monday 24th November 2014 at 7:41am

6 comments

#3643
stephen martin says:
November 22, 2014 at 05:34 pm

Ashelys track is the blue one and he looks like he overshot bleaklow stones and then navigated perfectly up to the stones (amazing). However, this was due to a very lucky (for Ashely) meeting with me as our paths crossed at 90 degrees in thick mist, since they were heading directly for the pennine way and snake pass, or even glossop! With no idea were they where claiming that Willy wasn't at the Bleaklow stones which they had visited some time ago (clearly Grina stones). Even then the draw of the snake proved irresistible and only Alport river saved them. They track also explains why they never visited the hole in the wall check point. They were very close then chose to veer away at the last minute to find a unique way down. I am sure these tracks would provide valuable data to scientists on the homing ability of humans. Still a great day out was had by all.

#3642
George Yates says:
November 21, 2014 at 10:29 pm

wtf. If ever there was a reason to put my new suunto in the bin this is it. What's wrong with just having a good run

#3641
Adrian Davis says:
November 21, 2014 at 11:25 am

I have a few spare places on my navigation course on the 24th December if anyone is interested?

#3640
mike browell says:
November 21, 2014 at 10:36 am

The upper part of the route reminds me of a sleeping cat with its right paw resting on the Horse Stone.    The two tracks follow the cats head perfectly.  This is not a mistake, some greater force has been at play.  The Egyptian cat god, Bast has been summoned.   Bast personified the playfulness, grace, affection, and cunning of a cat as well as the fierce power of a lioness.  I think that sums up the combined talents of Jim and Ashley.

Great minds do think alike, but in this case I think there has been some collusion.  Perhaps a bit of following the leader?

#3639
Loxley Crawshaw says:
November 21, 2014 at 08:35 am

Actually, thinking about this.  The 'Batman' is a good way to trace the life of a fell runner.  In the early years, you rise through the ranks until you hit your peak you then get complacent and dip a little before bobbling along for a few years, dreaming of the day when you can make your comeback.  You train hard for this comeback but when you finally peak, it feels like a hollow victory and instead of a comeback, it becomes your swansong and you quickly descend into the mediocre, you start riding bikes, looking at the Totley AC website and thinking Dave's Stella look appetising.  It will come to us all :-( and on that cheery note, I've got to plan my training for the weekend, I'm making a comeback. :-) 

#3638
Loxley Crawshaw says:
November 21, 2014 at 08:04 am

In the financial trading world I believe the top half of of this track is called a 'batman'  and it generally means the stock is going to tank and it's better to get out while you can! I know who took the direct line to horse stone so I will exempt myself from the chance of a pint. 

© Dark Peak Fell Runners 2018

Powered by Yii Framework